Original Anthony’s NY Pizza in Casselberry is one of those casual neighborhood spots where the food feels familiar in the best way. The mozzarella sticks and meatballs set the tone, generously portioned, comforting, and anchored by a standout marinara that brings brightness and depth. Wings are a solid add-on, but the real focus here is the chicken parmesan. The cutlet is thin, seasoned well, and fried to a satisfying crisp, topped with that same tangy, flavorful sauce and a classic melt of cheese. It’s not trying to reinvent the dish, and it doesn’t need to. A dependable, enjoyable chicken parm in a relaxed, friendly setting, worth a stop for a no-frills, sauce-forward fix.
