Papa Joe’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant is the definition of an old-school neighborhood Italian spot, and after nearly 40 years, it shows in all the right ways. The chicken parm delivers, with a thin, well-prepared cutlet, but the real standout is the sauce—rich, flavorful, and clearly the backbone of the dish. The chicken parm sub on a toasted sesame roll offers a fun contrast: one side crisp, the other soaked in sauce, giving you the best of both textures. Add in a solid pizza appetizer and classic atmosphere, and it’s easy to see why this place has lasted. A true local staple and Moe approved.
